Sandwich Isle

Situated conveniently on Kuhio Highway in picturesque Princeville, Sandwich Isle stands out as a beloved sandwich shop delivering a vibrant, fresh taste of Hawaii's North Shore. Specializing in creative, generously sized sandwiches made from the freshest local ingredients, this spot invites you to savor bold, satisfying flavors that perfectly complement a day of island adventure.

Sandwich Isle’s menu is a treasure trove for anyone craving a hearty and delicious meal on the go. Highlights like the Italian Job—a hot hoagie loaded with salami, capicola, pepperoni, mozzarella, and dressed with pickled sweet peppers, olives, and zesty Italian dressing—bring a medley of tangy, smoky, and savory notes that dance delightfully on the palate. The Surfer Turkey, layered with pepper jack cheese, creamy avocado, crisp sprouts, and chipotle aioli on local wheat, is a standout, praised for its fresh flavors and balanced spice. For those who appreciate a smoky, sweet twist, the Hawaiian Pulled Pork delivers rich, tender comfort nestled inside soft bread.

Beyond sandwiches, Sandwich Isle offers thirst-quenching drinks like freshly squeezed lemonade and Arnold Palmers, alongside the ever-refreshing iced tea. Complement your meal with the soup of the day—warm, comforting, and perfectly suited to island breezes. And for those seeking a unique island flavor, the Peanut Butter & Guava Jelly sandwich offers a sweet and creamy homage to Hawaiian taste traditions.

The inviting atmosphere at Sandwich Isle mirrors the warm island hospitality found in every interaction. Customers repeatedly praise the thoughtful, kind staff and the owner Courtney’s genuine care, creating a welcoming vibe whether you're dining in or grabbing takeout. Reviewers like Cassidy Begashaw highlight how these sandwiches are “delicious, filling and worth the money,” making them the perfect fuel for a beach day or a hike along the Na Pali Coast. Alison Fay chooses Sandwich Isle as a beloved first stop for lunch on the North Shore, raving about the fresh ingredients and “fantastic Mac nut pesto” that adds a unique twist to their lineup.

Those mindful of dietary concerns will appreciate the attentive service noted by Christopher Hawley, who experienced both great food and accommodating allergy considerations. For anyone seeking value, the hearty portions justify the price point, with customer firepaint33 praising the pastrami New Yorker and recommending eating fresh on warm days to fully enjoy the sandwich's vibrant texture and flavor.

For locals and visitors alike, Sandwich Isle is more than just a sandwich shop—it’s a flavorful island institution that delivers consistently fresh, imaginative meals with aloha spirit. Whether you’re craving a classic Italian sub or the bold, creamy notes of the Surfer Turkey, your taste buds are in for a treat that’s as satisfying as the stunning Hawaiian backdrop surrounding this charming eatery.